A Promised Land

In A Promised Land, the first volume of his highly anticipated presidential memoirs, Barack Obama provides a sweeping and vivid portrait of his life leading up to his entry into politics as an Illinois State Senator, and concluding in the midst of the third year of his presidency with Operation Neptune’s Spear, the mission to kill or capture Osama bin Laden. Mercifully, the memoir spends very little time on his early life, a mistake often made by long-winded memoirists who tend to reflect on their early years with something approaching myopic nostalgia. Obama limits the story of his early years to just a few pages, a mere setup to a long-lingering questioning of his early and murky career motives and the true objective of his decisions during that time. He quickly moves to his decision to run for office, first in the Illinois state senate, then rapidly to the U.S. Senate, followed by his run for the presidency. All along the way, he seems surprisingly and somewhat comfortingly irresolute, a shocking admission for a career politician. He also reflects on how Washington changes a person, worrying about being drawn into the muck of politics: "I questioned what might happen to me the longer I stayed in Washington, the more embedded and comfortable I became. I saw now how it could happen—how the incrementalism and decorum, the endless positioning for the next election, and the groupthink of cable news panels all conspired to chip away at your best instincts and wear down your independence, until whatever you once believed was utterly lost." Throughout the book, Barack Obama shows some real insight into his thoughts on partisanship. When reflecting on one of the big scandals of his election run where, in regard to why working class voters tend to elect Republicans, he made the comment, “So it’s not surprising then that they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy toward people who aren’t like them, or anti-immigrant sentiment, or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations.” He expresses a deep desire to recant that sentence and replace it with what he claims were his actual convictions as below: "“So it’s not surprising then that they get frustrated,” I would say in my revised version, “and they look to the traditions and way of life that have been constants in their lives, whether it’s their faith, or hunting, or blue-collar work, or more traditional notions of family and community. And when Republicans tell them we Democrats despise these things—or when we give these folks reason to believe that we do—then the best policies in the world don’t matter to them.”" Although this is obviously the rumination of a man who’s had a long opportunity to reflect on his mistakes, this comes across as earnest and believable. Obama’s writing seems to convey a true and pure desire to be a solid and equitable president who brings the country together. Although I had plenty of problems with his decisions and actions while he was president, when he reflects on many of those decisions, his earnestness is unambiguous and authentic, his motives plausibly benign. I voted for Obama in 2008, only the second time I had ever voted for a Democrat for president. (Clinton in 1996 was the first.) I didn’t vote for Obama because of his policies, or because of his messaging, both of which I mostly disagreed with at the time. I also didn’t vote for him because of his charisma or his oratory skills, or because of his message of “Hope.” In fact, I didn’t even vote for him again in 2012, choosing to return to my right-leaning views and vote for Mitt Romney. In 2008, I liked John McCain, and I thought that McCain would make a much better president than Barack Obama. And yet, I voted for Obama for one reason: Sarah Palin. Obama himself shares some interesting insight into the drama within his own campaign on hearing the news that McCain had chosen Palin, starting with Joe Biden turning to him and saying, “Who the hell is Sarah Palin?” After a deep dive by his team into her biography and background, Obama says this: "But from the day McCain chose her and through the heights of Palin-mania, I felt certain the decision would not serve him well. For all of Palin’s performative gifts, a vice president’s most important qualification was the ability, if necessary, to assume the presidency. Given John’s age and history of melanoma, this wasn’t an idle concern. And what became abundantly clear as soon as Sarah Palin stepped into the spotlight was that on just about every subject relevant to governing the country she had absolutely no idea what the hell she was talking about. The financial system. The Supreme Court. The Russian invasion of Georgia. It didn’t matter what the topic was or what form the question took—the Alaskan governor appeared lost, stringing words together like a kid trying to bluff her way through a test for which she had failed to study." Although this is an easy thing to state after the fact, I have to believe and agree with his assessment. This is after all the primary reason why I chose to vote for the candidate I felt at the time was the worst of the two choices. The book goes through the campaign and the race at a good pace, and he doesn’t dwell for too long on the election itself, getting quickly into the meat of his first year in office and the complex and challenging problems he inherited with a country and a world immersed in a financial crisis not seen since the Great Depression. Although both the House and the Senate were controlled by the Democrats, the Senate’s somewhat recent fixation and enthusiasm for the Filibuster made futile and exasperating his attempts at meaningful legislation. He spends a great deal of time reflecting on the confrontational nature of the Republican caucus toward any legislation put forth by his administration: "You might think that for a political party that had just suffered two cycles of resounding defeat, the GOP strategy of pugnacious, all-out obstruction would carry big risks. And during a time of genuine crisis, it sure wasn’t responsible. But if, like McConnell and Boehner, your primary concern was clawing your way back to power, recent history suggested that such a strategy made sense. For all their talk about wanting politicians to get along, American voters rarely reward the opposition for cooperating with the governing party." He goes into a short history lesson of the failures of both parties to win the house or senate via cooperation with the president through the last twenty years or so, a real but depressing look into how our government actually functions, with bitter infighting and iron-grip partisanship that puts personal power objectives well in front of the good of the country. Although he complains about this on numerous occasions, disappointingly he doesn’t cast blame on his own party for their own commensurate tactics with his Republican predecessors, nor does he offer a mediated solution to such deliberately damaging and abhorrent strategies. Admittedly, such a solution may be non-existent beyond congressional term-limits, which seems to be yet another idea that most Americans desire but will never be realized. The Global Financial Crisis of 2007-2008 caused by the sub-prime mortgage bubble was Obama’s immersion in fire, and it was a doozy, a real threat of an global economic depression that consumed the first part of his presidency. To this day, his administration’s handling of that crisis is still fiercely debated but, regardless of choices he could have made differently, there’s no doubt that his decisions did work in the end, and the U.S. banking industry certainly stabilized much quicker than any of its counterparts around the world. Obama certainly spends some time reflecting on what choices he could have made differently, as he states: "For many thoughtful critics, though, the fact that I had engineered a return to pre-crisis normalcy is precisely the problem—a missed opportunity, if not a flat-out betrayal. According to this view, the financial crisis offered me a once-in-a-generation chance to reset the standards for normalcy, remaking not just the financial system but the American economy overall. If only I had broken up the big banks and sent some white-collar culprits to jail; if only I had put an end to outsized pay packages and Wall Street’s heads-I-win, tails-you-lose culture, then maybe today we’d have a more equitable system that served the interests of working families rather than a handful of billionaires. I understand such frustrations. In many ways, I share them. To this day, I survey reports of America’s escalating inequality, its reduced upward mobility and still-stagnant wages, with all the consequent anger and distortions such trends stir in our democracy, and I wonder whether I should have been bolder in those early months, willing to exact more economic pain in the short term in pursuit of a permanently altered and more just economic order. The thought nags at me. And yet even if it were possible for me to go back in time and get a do-over, I can’t say that I would make different choices." I’m not qualified to judge the choices he made during this crisis—I’ll let the economists do that—but his insight into the thoughts that went behind those decisions is interesting, and his reasoning is certainly compelling. Obama adds just a small amount of humor to the book, such as this statement about German Chancellor, Angela Merkel: "She was famously suspicious of emotional outbursts or overblown rhetoric, and her team would later confess that she’d been initially skeptical of me precisely because of my oratorical skills. I took no offense, figuring that in a German leader, an aversion to possible demagoguery was probably a healthy thing." Obama also does a great job of describing and recognizing the bubble in which the American president sits, and his efforts to expand that bubble, from his visits to military hospitals or his attendance at the solemn return and transfer of American soldiers’ remains in an effort to understand the true cost of war, to his meeting with fifteen top American bankers during the financial crisis in an effort to understand their points of view, to his order to his Chief of Staff, Rahm, to have ten letters a day from citizens, good and bad, sent to him to read and reply to. He discusses his desire to take action on numerous occasions, desire that is tempered by his advisors, all of who’s expertise he respected and heeded. When talking about the Iranian revolts, the “Green Movement” of 2009 that posed one of the most significant challenges to the Islamic Republic in recent history, he stews over the merciless recriminations enacted by Ayatollah Ali Khamenei and President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. Publicly, he gives a series of bland, bureaucratic statements like, “We continue to monitor the entire situation closely,” but privately he balked at such passive action: "As the violence escalated, so did my condemnation. Still, such a passive approach didn’t sit well with me—and not just because I had to listen to Republicans howl that I was coddling a murderous regime. I was learning yet another difficult lesson about the presidency: that my heart was now chained to strategic considerations and tactical analysis, my convictions subject to counterintuitive arguments; that in the most powerful office on earth, I had less freedom to say what I meant and act on what I felt than I’d had as a senator—or as an ordinary citizen disgusted by the sight of a young woman gunned down by her own government." He also talks about the requisite tempering of his own ambitions and expectations with policy: "The presidency changes your time horizons. Rarely do your efforts bear fruit right away; the scale of most problems coming across your desk is too big for that, the factors at play too varied. You learn to measure progress in smaller steps—each of which may take months to accomplish, none of which merit much public notice—and to reconcile yourself to the knowledge that your ultimate goal, if ever achieved, may take a year or two or even a full term to realize. Nowhere is this truer than in the conduct of foreign policy." Although he doesn’t spend much more time on that concept, I can only imagine the frustration that someone with the temperament to run for the office of President of the United States must feel as such chafing and arduous delays. For example, the book ends shortly after the killing of Osama bin Laden, and Obama talks about the intelligence that led to the discovery of OBL’s hideout in Pakistan. That information was brought to him six months before Operation Neptune’s Spear was executed, and it’s hard to imagine learning that information and then compartmentalizing it for six months while it’s confirmed and a mission is drawn up. I have a hard time waiting a week or two for something I’m personally excited about like a vacation or a holiday, and the effort to control a natural impulsiveness to immediately take action regarding something as dramatic as intelligence that might lead to the execution or capture of bin Laden seems Herculean. Some of Obama’s candor and the bluntness with which he approaches his problems come through clearly in the opening of chapter 22: "It’s in the nature of politics, and certainly the presidency, to go through rough patches—times when, because of a boneheaded mistake, an unforeseen circumstance, a sound but unpopular decision, or a failure to communicate, the headlines turn sour and the public finds you wanting. Usually this lasts for a couple of weeks, maybe a month, before the press loses interest in smacking you around, either because you fixed the problem, or you expressed contrition, or you chalked up a win, or something deemed more important pushes you off the front page. If the rough patch lasts long enough though, you may find yourself in a dreaded situation in which problems compound, then congeal into a broader narrative about you and your presidency. The negative stories don’t let up, which leads to a drop in your popularity. Your political adversaries, smelling blood in the water, go after you harder, and allies aren’t as quick to defend you. The press starts digging for additional problems in your administration, to confirm the impression that you’re in political trouble. Until—like the daredevils and fools of old at Niagara Falls—you find yourself trapped in the proverbial barrel, tumbling through the crashing waters, bruised and disoriented, no longer sure which way is up, powerless to arrest your descent, waiting to hit bottom and hoping, without evidence, that you’ll survive the impact. For most of my second year in office, we were in the barrel." Obama’s team decides to arrest this descent into oblivion by pushing for Wall Street reform, culminating in the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, legislation that should have been completely bi-partisan, but because of what Obama claims was Republican obstinance toward anything he supported, was only able to clear Congress when Mitch McConnell secretly conveyed to him that he would allow the act to barely pass, their obstructionism working well for them and in full force. Once again, Obama takes the opportunity to disparage, or at least to show his frustration with Republicans and their backroom deals and insincere approach to political gamesmanship without acknowledging that this is a massive problem on both sides of the aisle, the muck and the “swamp” that would culminate in the election of Donald Trump eight years later. The book goes through the Deepwater Horizon incident, unrest in the middle east, the Arab Spring uprisings, our military intervention as part of the UN operation against Gaddafi’s forces in Libya, and Obama’s interactions with Russian puppet president Medvedev and his string-puller Putin. All of this is well-written, insightful, and a fascinating look behind the scenes that kept me mostly spellbound. Obama is not shy about self-criticism and acknowledgement of his own failings and errors throughout those early years of his presidency, and the humility is refreshing, gratifying, and relatable. He even reflects on the meaning of any of the choices he might have made with this statement toward the conclusion of the book: "Looking back, I sometimes ponder the age-old question of how much difference the particular characteristics of individual leaders make in the sweep of history—whether those of us who rise to power are mere conduits for the deep, relentless currents of the times or whether we’re at least partly the authors of what’s to come. I wonder whether our insecurities and our hopes, our childhood traumas or memories of unexpected kindness carry as much force as any technological shift or socioeconomic trend." This type of reflection is sporadically inserted throughout the book, the genuine thoughts of a man who had a clear, altruistic vision of what he wanted to accomplish as president. Whether he succeeded with this mission is certainly up for debate, but his motives are unquestionably not. A Promised Land was an enjoyable and enlightening read, and I highly recommend it. Although I was disappointed that it ended prior to what I feel was one of the biggest failures of his administration—Benghazi—I certainly understand the desire to end the book on a high note with the killing of Osama bin Laden. I’m eagerly looking forward to a similar level of authenticity and verisimilitude in volume two, hopefully sometime in the near future!

A Promised Land by Barack Obama “A Promised Land” is a fascinating first volume account of his presidential memoir; Barack Obama takes the reader on a historical journey of his first term. This anticipated book includes 27 chapters and is broken out by the following seven parts: 1. The Bet, 2. Yes We Can, 3. Renegade, 4. The Good Fight, 5. The World as It Is, 6. In the Barrel, and 7. On the High Wire. Positives: 1. Former President Obama is an excellent writer. The book is a pleasure to read. 2. Professional yet engaging tone. You appreciate Obama’s humility, intelligence and his high sense of duty and care of his fellow citizens. 3. This is an important book to read. It captures in a compelling manner the most important events of Obama’s first term. 4. In the Preface, Obama clearly establishes what this book is all about. “First and foremost, I hoped to give an honest rendering of my time in office—not just a historical record of key events that happened on my watch and important figures with whom I interacted but also an account of some of the political, economic, and cultural crosscurrents that helped determine the challenges my administration faced and the choices my team and I made in response.” 5. Describes briefly his days before becoming a politician. “AS LAW SCHOOL was coming to an end, I told Michelle of my plan. I wouldn’t clerk. Instead, I’d move back to Chicago, try to keep my hand in community work while also practicing law at a small firm that specialized in civil rights. If a good opportunity presented itself, I said, I could even see myself running for office.” 6. Keen political insights. “Whether I liked it or not, people were moved by emotion, not facts. To elicit the best rather than the worst of those emotions, to buttress those better angels of our nature with reason and sound policy, to perform while still speaking the truth—that was the bar I needed to clear.” 7. A look into the primaries. “Iowa may have convinced me and my team that I could end up being president. But it was the New Hampshire loss that made us confident I’d be up to the job.” 8. A look at Obama’s campaign versus McCain’s. “John McCain’s campaign had been flailing. Despite the fact that he’d wrapped up the Republican nomination three months before I secured mine, he hadn’t achieved much in the way of momentum. Swing voters remained unpersuaded by his proposal for further tax cuts on top of those Bush had already passed. In the new, more polarized climate, McCain himself appeared hesitant to even mention issues like immigration reform and climate change, which had previously burnished his reputation as a maverick inside his party. In fairness, he’d been dealt a bad hand. The Iraq War remained as unpopular as ever. The economy, already in recession, was rapidly worsening, and so were Bush’s approval numbers. In an election likely to hinge on the promise of change, McCain looked and sounded like more of the same.” 9. Putting together Obama’s team. “Choices in people reflected choices in policy, and with each choice, the chances of disillusionment grew.” 10. Discusses his agenda and important bills. “I signed my first bill into law on my ninth day in office: the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act.” 11. Discusses some of his challenges. “I also had to contend with a bit of institutionalized procedural mischief—the Senate filibuster—which in the end would prove to be the most chronic political headache of my presidency.” 12. The Recovery Act. “The next day, the Recovery Act passed the House 244 to 188 with precisely zero Republican votes. It was the opening salvo in a battle plan that McConnell, Boehner, Cantor, and the rest would deploy with impressive discipline for the next eight years: a refusal to work with me or members of my administration, regardless of the circumstances, the issue, or the consequences for the country.” 13. Keen political observations. “What Santelli understood, what McConnell and Boehner understood, was how easily that anger could be channeled, how useful fear could be in advancing their cause.” 14. The importance of process to make difficult decisions. “But with a sound process—one in which I was able to empty out my ego and really listen, following the facts and logic as best I could and considering them alongside my goals and my principles—I realized I could make tough decisions and still sleep easy at night, knowing at a minimum that no one in my position, given the same information, could have made the decision any better.” 15. Discusses Obama’s impact on the economy. “Not only did the U.S. banking sector stabilize far sooner than any of its European counterparts; the financial system and the overall economy returned to growth faster than those of just about any other nation in history after such a significant shock. If I had predicted on the day of my swearing in that within a year the U.S. financial system would have stabilized, almost all TARP funds would be fully repaid (having actually made rather than cost taxpayers money), and the economy would have begun what would become the longest stretch of continuous growth and job creation in U.S. history, the majority of pundits and experts would have questioned my mental fitness—or assumed I was smoking something stronger than tobacco.” 16. Interesting observations of foreign leaders. “Merkel, the daughter of a Lutheran pastor, had grown up in Communist East Germany, keeping her head down and earning a PhD in quantum chemistry. Only after the Iron Curtain fell did she enter politics, methodically moving up the ranks of the center-right Christian Democratic Union party with a combination of organizational skill, strategic acumen, and unwavering patience. Merkel’s eyes were big and bright blue and could be touched by turns with frustration, amusement, or hints of sorrow. Otherwise, her stolid appearance reflected her no-nonsense, analytical sensibility.” 17. Detailed discussion on Obama’s most important cause, a form of national healthcare system. “My instructions to Kathleen and the public health team were simple: Decisions would be made based on the best available science, and we were going to explain each step of our response to the public—including detailing what we did and didn’t know. Over the course of the next six months, we did exactly that.” Bonus, “On Christmas Eve, after twenty-four days of debate, with Washington blanketed in snow and the streets all but empty, the Senate passed its healthcare bill, titled the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act—the ACA—with exactly sixty votes. It was the first Christmas Eve vote in the Senate since 1895.” 18. The Supreme Court. “In theory, Supreme Court justices don’t “make law” when exercising these powers; instead, they’re supposed to merely “interpret” the Constitution, helping to bridge how its provisions were understood by the framers and how they apply to the world we live in today.” 19. Obama’s security philosophy. “I believed that America’s security depended on strengthening our alliances and international institutions. I saw military action as a tool of last, not first, resort.” 20. The impact of U.S. invasion of Iraq. “The U.S. invasion of Iraq had greatly strengthened Iran’s strategic position in the region by replacing its sworn enemy, Saddam Hussein, with a Shiite-led government subject to Iranian influence. Hezbollah, Iran’s proxy, had emerged as the most powerful faction in Lebanon, with Iranian-supplied missiles that could now reach Tel Aviv. The Saudis and Israelis spoke in alarming tones of an expanding “Shiite Crescent” of Iranian influence and made no secret of their interest in the possibility of a U.S.-initiated regime change.” 21. China and U.S. relations. “Instead of engaging in protectionism, America needed to take a page from the Chinese playbook. If we wanted to stay number one, we needed to work harder, save more money, and teach our kids more math, science, engineering—and Mandarin.” 22. The politics of climate change. “Over the next several years, carmakers and appliance manufacturers hit the higher efficiency goals we’d set without much fuss and ahead of schedule, confirming Steve’s assertion that when done properly, ambitious regulatory standards actually spurred businesses to innovate.” 23. The mindset of a president. “But as I’d discovered about myself during the campaign, obstacles and struggles rarely shook me to the core. Instead, depression was more likely to creep up on me when I felt useless, without purpose—when I was wasting my time or squandering opportunities. Even during my worst days as president, I never felt that way. The job didn’t allow for boredom or existential paralysis, and when I sat down with my team to figure out the answer to a knotty problem, I usually came away energized rather than drained.” 24. The Deepwater Horizon disaster. “The videos seemed to confirm calculations that our own analysts had made, independent of BP: The leaks were likely pumping out anywhere between four and ten times the original estimate of five thousand barrels of oil daily.” 25. Midterms. “The dominant story line in the postelection coverage suggested that the conventional wisdom had been right all along: that I’d attempted to do too much and hadn’t stayed focused on the economy; that Obamacare was a fatal error; that I’d tried to resurrect the kind of big-spending, big-government liberalism that even Bill Clinton had pronounced dead years ago.” 26. The economy. “The laws’ changes to the estate tax alone had reduced the tax burden for the top 2 percent of America’s richest families by more than $130 billion. Not only that, but by taking roughly $1.3 trillion in projected revenue out of the U.S. Treasury, the laws had helped turn a federal budget surplus under Bill Clinton into a burgeoning deficit—a deficit that many Republicans were now using to justify their calls for cuts to Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, and the rest of America’s social safety net.” 27. The Middle East. “In other words, the absence of peace between Israel and the Palestinians made America less safe.” 28. A great chapter on the hunt for bin Laden. “The second option was to authorize a special ops mission, in which a select team would covertly fly into Pakistan via helicopter, raid the compound, and get out before the Pakistani police or military had time to react. To preserve the secrecy of the operation, and deniability if something went awry, we’d have to conduct it under the authority of the CIA rather than the Pentagon. On the other hand, for a mission of this magnitude and risk, we needed a topflight military mind—which is why we had the Defense Department’s Vice Admiral William McRaven, head of Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC), in the room to walk us through what a raid might entail.” 29. A photo insert. Negatives: 1. At around 700 pages this book will require your commitment and time. 2. It only covers the first term of Obama’s two-term presidency. 3. Lack of supplementary material, I would have added a timeline of key events. 4. No notes or links. In summary, this is a must read. President Obama is a gifted writer and he provides readers with keen insights into the most important events of his first term. You get to relive those moments through the eyes of President Obama and gain a better understanding of the challenges he faced. A riveting account of history, a five-star book if there ever was one. Further recommendations: “Barack Obama: The Audacity of Hope” by Barack Obama, “TIME Barack Obama: Eight Years” by The Editors of Time, “Who Thought This Was a Good Idea” by Alyssa Mastromonaco, “The World as It Is” by Ben Rhodes, “A Consequential President: The Legacy of Barack Obama, “Becoming” by Michelle Obama, “The Black Presidency: Barack Obama and the Politics of Race in America” by Michael Eric Dyson, and “Obama’s Legacy: What He Accomplished as President” by Michael I. Days.

I’m giving the first volume of Obama’s memoirs, A Promised Land, five stars not because I voted for him in both 2008 and 2012. Not because I agree with most of his politics and share his overall concerns for the world. Not because I regard him as a successful president. Not because I admire him as a man of dignity and integrity. Not because I respect him as a loving and devoted husband and father. Rather, the reason I’m giving volume one of his memoirs five stars is because it’s an outstanding piece of historical literature. And also, because it’s an engaging, thoughtful, and insightful reading experience, where Obama’s voice resonates with remarkable honesty and candor. Never faltering throughout 700 pages, Obama demonstrates his tremendous reflective ability to see and admit his faults and shortcomings, even as he, of course, lauds his achievements and accomplishments, yet he always remains grateful in crediting the innumerable people who aided and supported his journey. He has the mind of a scholar to grasp the complexity of history, and he recounts events with astute commentary and also with a riveting degree of suspense. He exemplifies the conscience of a leader to consider every angle of an issue, and he shares his determination and offers up his open-mindedness to pursue politics as an endeavor to enact policy that enables everyone to have an opportunity, especially the downtrodden, underprivileged, and disadvantaged. His prose over 700 pages also never flags in its steady brilliance and beauty. His words are elegantly composed; they are commanding, inspiring, and full of flair and flow. He may drift into verbosity at times, but his thoughts echo with sincerity borne of deeply contemplative reflection. I simply experienced great joy in reading his work because he managed to express his genuine humanness in the full spectrum of what it means to be one of the world’s most influential and scrutinized individuals: he is both humble and boastful, confessional and regretful, apologetic and unapologetic, critical and commending, funny and indignant, sagacious and dismissive, stubborn and fair, cynical and idealistic, concerned and optimistic. What resonated most with me, however, was his uncompromised commitment to maintaining his humanity while pursuing and fulfilling a life of public service. In this regard, his memoir profoundly expressed his vulnerability, his confidence, his sacrifices, his disappointments, and ultimately his empathy and compassion to try and do what is right to engage and help others and to improve the decency, civility, and equality of democracy in America and around the world. I marked dozens of passages throughout Obama’s memoir, so it was difficult to choose a few that most aptly embody the intellect of his thoughts and vision and also the essence of his hopes and concerns. Here are three that I decided upon: “The idea that our common humanity mattered more than our differences was stitched into my DNA. It also described what I felt was a practical view of politics: In a democracy, you needed a majority to make big change, and in America that meant building coalitions across racial and ethnic lines.” (115) “The young people I met in those town halls were a steady source of personal inspiration. They made me laugh and sometimes made me tear up. In their idealism, they reminded me of the youthful organizers and volunteers who had propelled me into the presidency, and of the bonds we share across racial, ethnic, and national boundaries when we learn to set aside our fear. No matter how frustrated or discouraged I might have felt going in, I always came out of those town halls feeling recharged, as if I’d been dipped in a cool forest spring. So long as young men and women like that exist in every corner of this earth, I told myself, there is reason enough to hope.” (449) “Except now I found myself asking whether those impulses—of violence, greed, corruption, nationalism, racism, and religious intolerance, the all-too-human desire to beat back our own certainty and mortality and sense of insignificance by subordinating others—were too strong for any democracy to permanently contain. For they seemed to lie in wait everywhere, ready to resurface whenever growth rates stalled or demographics changed or a charismatic leader chose to ride the wave of people’s fears and resentments. And as much as I might have wished otherwise, there was no Mahatma Gandhi around to tell me what I might do to hold such impulses back.” (602-603)

Regardless of one's politics, there is no doubt about the historic importance of Obama's presidency. Through this book, Obama takes us through the first three years of his time in office, provides a uniquely personal view, and does so with a precise and elegant use of the language. There is very little space devoted to his pre-presidency years. Instead, Obama focuses on the period from 2007 through 2011 and particularly his time as President from 2009 until mid-2011. For most of the book, he covers issues or topics like healthcare reform, climate change, foreign policy, the oil spill, financial reform, and others. For each issue, he gives a brief but useful background and summary. For example, before he writes about his own work related to the Middle East crisis, Obama explains the historical context of the problem and how we got here. He then delves into his personal experiences. I found that initial context-setting very useful. Obama's treatment of his involvement in various issues is done in a balanced manner. I say this because I have read several books about his presidency and the narratives tie quite well. It does appear that he may have glossed over certain uncomfortable situations, such as the alleged rift between Michelle Obama and Robert Gibbs. Also, curiously, there is very little space devoted to Hillary's work as Secretary of State. The book is not a fast read. Obama writes like he speaks, with carefully chosen words and a well-connected set of thoughts, often fairly complex. It is not uncommon for a sentence in the book to read like this, well-written and presenting a cogent thought before he adds the dreaded "hyphen" - and within the hyphen, he presents an adjacent but somewhat independent point, explained in a lot of detail, and somewhat long, so that by the time you have understood the content within the hyphen, you have lost the pre-hyphen content - and then you need to look up to see where you were before the hyphen. Jokes apart, the writing is complex but not tedious. Also, Obama chooses words with precision and intent. Even everyday words seem to be chosen with care. So when he calls Mitch McConnell "shameless", it feels that he uses the word with a specific intent, rather than using it as a venting of his frustration (just to clarify, I don't have a considered opinion on the appropriateness of that description). So much of Obama's presidency has been written about. One wonders if there is truly more to learn. Thankfully there is. Obama shares personal stories which are illuminating. An episode where he spent time in a park right after his 2004 speech, and experienced firsthand his rapidly growing popularity, is interesting and humorous. He shares a private habit he had when he wrote condolence letters to families of fallen service members. That description shows his decency and sensitivity as a leader and as a human being. The summaries of his conversations with various world leaders are also helpful in understanding history from his personal lens. In summary, this is a very well written book that gives the reader a firsthand account of an important and historic time in our nation's history. That the narrator has a natural gift of expression only adds to the experience. Highly recommended!!

A good read.

There are many reasons why this book earns five stars and is worth a read. First, Obama has grown as a writer. Having read the two previous autobiographical works, this reviewer believes he has honed his craft. There are moments where prose verges into poetry and the reader gets a sense that the author, who writes in long hand, measured his words carefully. "Do we care to match the reality of America to its ideals?" or "The America I believed in was possible, that the democracy I believed in was in reach." It becomes, at times, both inspiring and insightful. This is a writer who reads voraciously and savors the power of words. Second, Obama takes the reader behind the scenes in all aspects of his Presidency. The primary trail is long and has a steep learning curve. There are successes, but missteps too. A Presidential transition is awkward, but essential not only for the Presidents, but also for their spouses and children. The reader gets a peek at the backstage of Inauguration Day and sits in on the laborious vetting for the President's staff. Like the making of sausage, writing and passing legislation are not pretty. Many hours are spent by both the President and his staff in honing the text, meeting with legislators, cajoling members of Congress, re-writing, counting votes and editing one more time to get passage. Compromise can be the key to success. A similar process takes place on the world stage as the reader attends G8, G20, UN and Climate Conferences. Obama shares his own power on the world stage as well as the influence of other leaders. Finally, this is an extremely personal and emotional book. There are moments where Obama lays bare his feelings about paternal abandonment, the depth of his love for his nuclear family, his insecurities and fears. His determination to "get it right" is not always attainable. He shares the joy of success and the tears of failure. He approaches tasks cerebrally and with hours of labor with minute attention to details. Much was accomplished during his first term, but there is more to come in the next volume. This reviewer can't wait to read the next installment.

Full disclosure: I am an Obama fan. I respect the man and admire just about everything I know about him. I am half way through the book and can't put it down. (Luckily I'm retired so I can indulge myself.) Obama always struck me as trying to be true to his goals while remaining practical and moderate. His voice comes through clearly--moderated by the awareness he is speaking in public, so there is a level of carefulness in his tone. This is a man who trusts his intellect, which is active and deep, and he trusts his logic. He makes a warm heart and enormous empathy visible. You cannot run for president without an ego and active ambition, and both are evident here but without the abrasiveness and/or insincerity too many other politicians demonstrate. Obama seems to measure himself by what he gets done-- and the quality of that work -- more than whether he is universally loved. He understands that he can't get everything he wants, so moderation is reasonable. He is careful in his description of others. I would love to get him a couple of beers and then ask what he thinks of Mitch McConnell. . His generous and careful credit-giving to nearly anyone he has ever worked with, or who worked for him, is nice but a little exhausting. He does not provide character studies of the politicians and bureaucrats in his life, but limits himself to quick, generally factual, summaries. He can damn with faint praise as well. For example, I have the impression that while he finds Nancy Pelosi admirable and very effective, he is unlikely to invite her to spend a beach weekend with his family. I am looking forward to his impressions of Donald Trump but I gather that is in volume two. I am very grateful that Obama writes well--very clearly, with same lighter, un-ponderous touch that made his speeches so effective. He also has a habit I have been trying to break in my writing--he makes lots of parenthetical asides. I love that (she says guiltily). Obama is driven by his ideals, and tried to make them live in a grittier world. This is a nearly impossible goal. This autobiography, so far, lives up to what I was hoping and I am enjoying it enormously.

I felt I got to know Obama, and ultimately decided to vote for him, through his first memoir, Dreams from my Father, so I was not hesitant to pick up this book, even though it is only half of the memoir and I had to pay FULL PRICE for it! It delivered what I expected. Obama is a truly gifted writer. His prose verges on the poetic and presents a picture of a warm, caring man who loves his family and enjoys shooting hoops with friends or kids and at the same time shows extreme intelligence and a grasp of complex issues. The book presented beautifully the issues that faced his presidency and amounts to a well-done history of the era on issues like the Mideast problems and the 2008 economic collapse. At the same time it gives vivid details that let me see what it is like actually to be President. A good example is when Obama had to order military action on Syria while he was visiting Brazil and his secure communications network failed to work! So he finally borrowed a cell phone from an advisor to call the Joint Chief of Staff and tell him " 'You have my authorization'. And with those words, spoken into a device that had probably been used to order pizza, I initiated the first new military intervention of my presidency." Sometimes, though, the details are so specific I wonder how much he indulges in literary license. For example, during the incident above he says, "As our communications technicians rushed about..., I sat down in a chair and scooped a handful of almonds from a bowl on a side table." Can he really remember that? If not, does it really matter? Maybe not when it comes to snaking on almonds, but then what details might he add that I might think WOULD matter? Despite my HIGH admiration for the book I sometimes got rather impatient with its detail and interposed other books in between sections. I do not know if the fault was his or mine. I also felt he devoted too much time to his life before he became president, since it was presented to be a book about his presidency.

It took me over two years to finish reading this book , obviously not in one go but in two times ,I downloaded it straight away when was published and after reading approximately hundred pages I just put it down and not because English wasn't my mother tongue but because I found it a bit boring and not gossip juicy but two or three weeks ago I started reading it again and this time somehow it started growing in me and I started to appreciate Barack writing that is brutally good with a very rich colourful vocabulary and remembering until the last tiny memory of his life as president and before,the thing I liked the most about the book is all the anecdotes he tells about his meetings with another world leaders,so anyway I recommend this book to everyone that have the slightest interest in Barack or politics and of course to everyone that's learning English and want to do improve their overall English reading skills.A last thing I'd like to point out is that for all those Spanish people that buy the book expecting to read about Obama relationship with Spain or our Prime Minister you will be very disappointed because the word Spain is only mentioned once in over 700 pages and was just to list a bunch of countries.

An expectedly well-written, thoughtful and compelling account of Obama’s inspirational rise to America’s highest political office followed by his hectic, crisis-ridden first term in office. Obama is an eloquent and gifted writer, who not only understands the underlying power of well-crafted language and rhetoric, but utilises this extraordinary talent of his in a way that depicts his inner struggles, feelings and contradictions in a colourful and truly evocative way. The book offers a thrilling literary journey into the vast machinery of US decision-making and the complexities encountered in the course of navigating through multiple domestic and international crises simultaneously. When it comes to substance, A Promised Land offers a detailed, personal account of Obama’s political formation, his experience as a student and an activist, and the gradual emergence of his liberal, idealistic worldview. It is, at times, a truly intimate account of the political rollercoaster that defined the era of his first term. The book itself is structured into separate parts that cover major themes: the first part of the volume focuses on Obama’s journey to assuming office, whilst the latter part covers the first term of his presidency. The consequential thread of events is covered seamlessly, although at times it feels as if the sheer breadth and enormity of the task the author had embarked upon reduced the allotted time he could spend on certain topics (understandable, given the huge palette of editorial decisions involved in ensuring that the final volume provides a thorough and engaging account of all keys events). Personally, the parts I enjoyed the most were those devoted to: Obama’s upbringing; his personal history; and, then, the detailed account of his administration’s foreign policy decisions. It was truly insightful to step into the mind of the man who had to contemplate the most serious and consequential of decisions, and to read through his personal assessments of diplomatic negotiations as well as America’s complex role in today’s increasingly multipolar world. Most importantly, Obama’s personal account of his time in office offers a reminder that decency, integrity and respect CAN be part of modern political discourse. No matter his pitfalls, shortcomings and failures as president, his leadership skills and ethical standards show that a leader’s most important skill today is to fully comprehend the sheer gravity of his actions and the far-reaching consequences of his decisions.

I'm not from the US so it would be hard for me to properly rate Obama as a president. However I'm an avid reader so I will say that this memoir is probably the best written POTUS memoir I've ever read. It mainly covers (most of) his first term in office, as well as his initial campaigns (for his nomination and then the presidential race). I appreciate him casting some light on his thought process for his decisions on some of the international issues, and I also appreciate him acknowledging that at times he was uncertain, or that he made mistakes. The tidbits about the internal quabbles and tit-for-tat in politics were also very interesting. But what I appreciate most is that throughout the book he focused a lot on the support he received of his wife and family, friends, colleagues and staff, illustrating well how even being the president is far from being a one-man show.

In this powerful book, Obama shares his passionate journey to become the first black president of the United States, a milestone in American history. Surely, this a fascinating, deeply personal account of history in the making. From his earliest political aspiration in Illinois to Iowa caucus and finally the victory of presidential election, we can see his strength and resilience under pressure and how he handled complex situations and at the same time kept his mind and conscience on high standards. He describes what is to be the commander in chief and manage huge financial crisis, Influenza outbreak, massive oil leaking, the Arab Spring, two wars and a stormy political scenario. He bring us inside the Oval Office and to uncountable tough meetings he had to manage as if we were right there, inside his mind. Through his intimate and introspective writing he detailed how he and his team build the Affordable Care Act, Recovery Act, DREAM, and other crucial advances in American politics. This a highly recommended book.

As a person who doesn't know much about politics, I found this book very informative about how politics work, I found Mr. Obama very humble, giving credit where credit is due from down the ladder all the way to the top, whether you are the gardener or a top executive, I love his subtle humor, I love that he is able to separate the public persona from the person. He might not like your politics but he is still able to like you as a person. I thought he was able to analyze situation very clearly, taking into account the human side of an issue, not taking decisions lightly without considering all the sides of an issue. I also like that he knows his strengths and his weaknesses and that he could surround himself with people who had the forces of his weaknesses instead of Yesman. That shows humility, that shows intelligence, that shows that you are not taking that job lightly. To use his own words to describe Steven Chu, his secretary, of energy "he has a gift for explaining highly-technical issues in terms that smaller-brained humans like me could actually understand". It applies to his writing too. Loved every page of that book, it was never boring and I intend to read his previous books.